12 Comments
deletedMar 27, 2023Liked by Lorenzo Warby
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Mar 22, 2023Liked by Helen Dale, Lorenzo Warby

Excellent stuff.

As I’ll explore in a later essay, the pandemic policy responses did not make sense if public health was the goal. If, however, hoarding authority and maximising resources to public health, while minimising the complexities of competence, were the functional goals, Covid-19 responses made perfect sense.

I look forward to reading that essay. Thanks!

Expand full comment
Mar 22, 2023Liked by Helen Dale, Lorenzo Warby

I wonder whether Lorenzo could assemble these essays into a book. That would be a great thing to have.

Expand full comment
Mar 22, 2023Liked by Helen Dale, Lorenzo Warby

I am quite taken aback by the extent to which I've come to almost universally similar conclusions. I take such instances of convergent evolution as evidence that my perception is aligning well with reality. I would love to have a discussion with you at some point.

Expand full comment
Mar 22, 2023Liked by Helen Dale, Lorenzo Warby

The writing initially struck me as a little bit disjointed, but this piece grew on me.

It was refreshing to see laid bare so many of the actual realities underlying the human condition that some expect me to just ignore.

Incentives matter, people have different inherent capabilities and desire which are stratified across all kinds of categories, bureaucracies do perpetuate themselves and thus attempt to increase their authority and scope, children are not adults, everyday systems of social life do reward and punish people based on what is valued this can be deranging.

Looking forward to the next piece!

Expand full comment
Nov 23, 2023Liked by Lorenzo Warby

“When the progressive approach of ‘politically handing out the social goodies’ (relying on bureaucracies treated as if they were systematically altruistically competent) became dominant, various indicators of social progress among the descendants of American slaves either stalled or cratered.”

My father-in-law worked with victims of Hansen’s Disease - leprosy. One of the symptoms was a loss of the sense of touch. People with the disease could hurt themselves terribly by continuing to walk on a broken or twisted ankle or by putting their hand on a hot stove without knowing it. Leprosy breaks the feedback loop connecting cause and effect.

Doting parents and paternalistic governments can create a sort of moral leprosy by relieving children and others from the need to face the consequences of their own actions. Unfortunately, this often means that innocent people must bear those consequences. As the penalties for destructive and self-destructive actions are eliminated, and as the rewards for productive behavior are reduced, we can expect destructive activity to increase and productive activity to decrease.

Expand full comment